India News | HC Dismisses Bail Plea of Woman
Get latest articles and stories on India at LatestLY. The Kerala High Court on Wednesday dismissed the bail plea of the woman accused in the human sacrifice case in which two other women were allegedly killed, saying that if she was granted there was every chance that she may influence the witnesses.
Kochi, Jan 4 (PTI) The Kerala High Court on Wednesday dismissed the bail plea of the woman accused in the human sacrifice case in which two other women were allegedly killed, saying that if she was granted there was every chance that she may influence the witnesses.
"If bail is granted, there is the stark reality of justice being thwarted. Thus the circumstances do not lean in favour of the grant of bail to the petitioner (accused)," Justice Bechu Kurian Thomas said and rejected the plea for bail moved by Laila Bhagawal Singh, one of the three accused in the case.
Also Read | Karnataka Murugha Mutt Seer Sex Scandal: No Sign of Rape of Minor Girls, Says Medical Examination Report.
The court declined to also give her the benefit that a woman enjoys under the proviso to section 437 of the Criminal Procedure Code (CrPC).
The proviso to section 437 of CrPC states that while considering a bail plea of an accused, if they are sick, infirm or a woman, the court may grant them the relief even if there were reasonable grounds to believe they are guilty of an offence for which the punishment is death or life imprisonment, the High Court noted.
Justice Kurian said the benefit to be given to women under that provision was discretionary and "not mandatory" and merely because the accused was a woman, the court cannot ignore the nature and gravity of the offence, possibility of influencing witnesses and likelihood of the crime being repeated and justice being thwarted.
The court said that in the instant case, the manner in which the murders were committed was "horrifying", "gruesome" and "shocking".
"The offences alleged against the petitioner and other accused apparently reveal a human sacrifice. It is, no doubt, a horrendous crime. The nature and gravity of the accusation are gruesome, apart from being shocking...The circumstances of the case, as mentioned earlier, are horrifying.
"The active involvement of the petitioner in the crime and in another crime is asserted by the prosecution and the materials collected, prima facie reveal her involvement in the present crime. The various circumstances of the case are overwhelmingly leaning against the petitioner, and the benefit of the proviso to section 437 CrPC cannot be exercised in her favour," the court said.
The court further said that in view of her prima facie involvement in the crime, it was of the view that she cannot be released on bail.
"Accordingly, I dismiss this bail application," Justice Kurian said.
The lawyer of the accused had claimed in court that the allegation of the prosecution against her were unbelievable, there was nothing to connect her with the crimes and she was at best only a spectator to the killings.
The prosecution, on the other hand, opposing grant of bail, said she was actively involved in the crimes and there was a possibility that she also indulged in cannibalism.
Director General of Prosecution T A Shaji said many of the witnesses are her relatives and, therefore, her release could cause great prejudice.
Agreeing with the prosecution, the court said the circumstances prima facie reveal that she was an active participant in the crime.
"Suffice to say, there are materials connecting the petitioner to the crime, at least prima facie," the court said.
Besides her, the other two accused are Bhagawal Singh, her husband and also a massage therapist, along with Mohammed Shafi, a history-sheeter.
According to the police remand report, the victims were not only killed, their bodies were mutilated and chopped into pieces.
The chopped body parts of the deceased were exhumed from the premises of the couple's house at Elanthoor village in Pathanamthitta district on October 11, 2022.
The first woman went missing on September 26, 2022 and the probe led to Shafi.
On interrogating him, police found that the trio had earlier murdered the second victim in a similar manner in June last year.
Both women -- Roslin and Padma -- sold lottery tickets to earn a living, police had said.
According to the remand report, Roslin was persuaded by prime accused Shafi after promising Rs 10 lakh to act in a porn film and brought to the crime site. The report also said it was Laila who murdered her.
Padma, who went missing in September, was offered Rs 15,000 for sex and lured to the couple's home by Shafi, according to the report.
While investigating into Padma's disappearance, police found Shafi's involvement which led them to the couple. Only thereafter, did the police come to know about the murder of Roslin in June 2022 by the trio. PTI
(The above story is verified and authored by Press Trust of India (PTI) staff. PTI, India’s premier news agency, employs more than 400 journalists and 500 stringers to cover almost every district and small town in India.. The views appearing in the above post do not reflect the opinions of LatestLY)